As published in CLSF News, Vol 10 Issue 5, August 2001
![]()
Several children with CLS, my son included, have experienced breathing difficulties after undergoing anesthesia—the airways closed and breathing was obstructed. In Davis’s case, his throat suddenly closed about 24 hours after his scoliosis surgery—he turned blue and had to have his airways forced open again with air pressure. It happened again 30 minutes later. Needless to say, this is very scary.
The following article addresses the incidence of these types of complications in the general population. We have no way of knowing at this time how much higher the risks are for CLS children than the general population, although there is evidence in other syndromes that the risks are higher in children who have low muscle tone or abnormal jaw or airway construction. I conducted an informal survey among the parents and found that 3 out of 6 of those children who underwent anesthesia reported complication. —MCH
For the complete text of the following article, please see:
http://www.sambahq.org/professional-info/education/previous-meetings/1998-annual/controversies.html
MEHERNOOR F. WATCHA, M.D.
In this talk we shall review the factors associated with increased post-discharge complication rates, and what actions anesthesiologists can take to reduce this. As previous speakers have discussed the role of preoperative evaluation, general, regional and sedation techniques, these will not be discussed in detail except where they concern the possibility of post-anesthetic complications. However, it is obvious that post-discharge complications cannot be considered in isolation but as part of the overall management of the patient extending from the preoperative evaluation till the patient is ready to resume normal daily activities.
Recovery from ambulatory surgery occurs in three phases—early, intermediate and late. Early or Phase 1 recovery occurs in the Post-Anesthesia Care Unit where close observation by a nurse is essential until the patient demonstrates return to consciousness, the ability to maintain a patent airway and normal oxygen saturation in room air. During this phase, the patient is recumbent and the nurse-patient ratio is usually 1:2 or lower. In the intermediate phase (Phase 2 recovery) the patient continues to recover sitting up in a chair or often on the parent’s lap. Patient care is usually provided by the parents during this phase and the routine of frequent cardio-respiratory monitoring by the nurses that was justified during Phase 1 often upsets the child and may be limited during Phase 2 recovery. The third or final phase occurs at home where the child gradually returns to a normal playful level of activity and the caretakers resume their daily routine.
Postanesthetic complications may occur during any of the 3 phases of recovery, but the serious problems occur most often during Phase 1. These include hypoxemia during transport from the operating room to the Post Anesthesia Care Unit, bleeding, airway obstruction, croup, pain, nausea and vomiting, emergence delirium. In Phase 2 the major problems relate to bleeding, nausea and vomiting, pain, dizziness and excessive drowsiness. In Phase 3 problems reported include pain, nausea and vomiting, bleeding and behavioral changes.
INCIDENCE OF COMPLICATIONS
There are few large studies of the overall mortality and morbidity associated with anesthesia in pediatric patients. These include a study from Canada, a study from France and the Closed Claims study from the USA. The intraoperative complication rates for neonates and infants are higher than for older children or adults. The overall major complication rates for pediatric inpatients have been reported as 7 per 10,000 in another study, but again the rate in infants was much higher (43 per 10,000 vs. 5 per 10,000 for older children).3 However, the intraoperative complication rates for older children (beyond 2 years of age) are similar to those in adults (9/10,000 children vs. 10.6/10,000 adults). In contrast, the postoperative complication rates are much higher in children, with major life-threatening events occurring in about 4% of children vs. 0.5% of adults.
These differences are even more marked when the rates for minor complications are compared. In the Canadian study, approximately 21% of children had minor complications in the first three postoperative days compared to 9.4% of adults. The most common problems in neonates were respiratory and cardiovascular, while older children were more likely to develop nausea and vomiting, sore throat, headache and muscle pains. This may be misleading as the younger child [or developmentally delayed—MCH] is unable to express these symptoms. It must be remembered that these data refer to both inpatients and outpatients. It is highly likely that the incidence of the minor complications will be higher in the outpatient population.
Respiratory Complications:
Children may develop hypoxemia following postoperative respiratory complications such as upper airway obstruction, laryngospasm, apnea, and postintubation croup. Upper airway obstruction in the immediate postoperative period is very common in this patient population, particularly following otolaryngological operations such as tonsillo-adenoidectomy. The anesthesiologist must be very aware of the breathing pattern of the child during transport from the operating room to the PACU. The combination of hypoventilation from airway obstruction and residual volatile agents may further depress respiratory drive, increasing blood carbon dioxide tension. This may set off a vicious cycle of hypoxemia, hypercarbia, further depression of respiration and ultimately result in cardiac dysrhythmias and finally cardiac arrest. Airway manipulation with the jaw thrust maneuver, neck extension, and mouth opening may not always be enough to correct the problem. Positive pressure with a bag and face mask may be required along with a naso-pharyngeal airway, and if necessary a dose of succinylcholine followed by tracheal re-intubation. The presence of secretions in the oro-pharynx may be responsible for these complications. However, data have not shown that extubating the trachea when the patient is fully awake leads to decreased hypoxemia compared to tracheal extubation while deeply anesthetized.
Anesthesiologists should anticipate increased airway problems in three groups of children: (a) those with a history of a recent upper respiratory tract infection, particularly if they have undergone tracheal intubation, (b) former premature infants and (c) children with chronic, obstructive sleep apnea. A more recently recognized factor for increased perioperative respiratory difficulties is exposure to secondhand tobacco smoke. Children from families where one or more members smoke have a higher incidence of respiratory problems following surgery and this is correlated with urine cotinine levels, a metabolite of nicotine. Children with upper respiratory infections have airway irritability well after they are asymptomatic.Apnea may be central, obstructive or mixed and is defined as cessation of breathing for 15 seconds or for less than 15 seconds if associated with pallor, cyanosis or bradycardia. Briefer pauses without bradycardia are termed periodic breathing, which is normal in some neonates. The probability of apnea in the former premature infant is inversely proportional to gestational and postconceptual age.
Children with chronic obstructive sleep apnea constitute another group with a predilection to hypoxemia and postoperative apnea. A significant incidence of postoperative respiratory distress, need for oxygen and intensive monitoring has been reported in children below 3-years who have undergone tonsillectomy. These data strongly suggest there is a need for admitting such children overnight for observation, oxygen and fluid therapy. Chest X-rays, ECG and polysomnograms have not been shown to be useful in predicting which patients can be safely managed on an ambulatory basis.Airway obstruction in the postoperative period also occurs in children who develop post-intubation croup. The incidence seems to be decreasing as anesthesiologists have started using smaller tracheal tubes and ensuring there is an air leak below 30-40 cms water pressure. Cuffed tracheal tubes have been used in small children in the ICU without an increased incidence of croup, suggesting that we re-examine the practice of using uncuffed tracheal tubes in children. Perhaps the wider use of steroids during adeno-tonsillectomies, one of the most common pediatric operations, may be a factor in the decrease in postintubation croup.
![]()